David Gilmour or Roger Waters ?

[JimmyPage1]

Honestly, I think Roger is a better songwriter than David. But I prefer David's voice and guitar playing better. I also feel like David has a better personality, idk he seems nicer ? Roger is a really cool dude too, but I pick Dave on this one

 

[RedDevilm'sCourtney]

David Gilmour

 

[LeAWoman]

David Gilmour, the voice and guitar of Pink Floyd

 

[Zero]

Roger Waters as you said it's a better songwriter and from the album The Wall he was the Lead Singer and it rocked . David Gilmour is a beast with the guitar and he has a good voice too i love how he sings in the album the division bell so I can say they both are great but David went well even after Rogers left Pink Floyd he still continued like a machine .

 

[LeAWoman]

David Gilmour, the voice and guitar of Pink Floyd

 

[kate]

David Gilmour by far.

 

[david]

Roger.