Which first car? Audi A5 vs Audi A4 vs BMW 328ix Sedan vs Mercedes-Benz...

[Broski]

...C300 Sport Sedan 4matic? I am an 18 year old male getting my first car soon, yes i can afford the payment, maintenance, and insurance, so i DONT WANT ANY OLD BEATER SUGGESTIONS, IT IS DEFINITELY ONE OF THESE. I was wondering which is the best for a fairly new driver. here is what I have come up with so far, for pros and cons. Oh yeah, i live in a snowy area, so i need AWD.

Audi A5-
pro: Best looks IMO (though not a major thing)
pro:Best interior
Con: Priciest
Con:coupe, so it is hard to get in and out of, and smallest space, is there enough room?

Audi A4
Pro: Lowest cost
Pro:Sedan, easy with friends, roomy
Pro: Still has audi styling in and out
Con: seems like a downgraded A5, or is it?

BMW 328ix
Pro: sedan good with friends, roomy
Nothing else, anything else?

Mercedes-Benz C300
Pro: Apparently most comfortable
Pro: Brand prestige (minimal factor though)
Con: tight space for a sedan

This is what I have, and I was wondering which car is the best out of these, PLEASE TELL WHY.
Thanks!

 

[Nick]

I think i answered this one before, but could i make a recommendation? Since you're already looking at a Benz C300, maybe you should consider a used C63 AMG for around the same price? Comfy and super brand prestige, if not then choose whatever is most comfy because all of these are fast, remember you're probably gonna want to drive your friends around.

 

[Shane]

1.) Audi A5
2.) BMW 328xi
3.) Audi A4
4.) Mercedes-Benz C300

My order & ranking is based on looks, features, performance, and interior.

Also if you live in a snowy area, be SURE you get AWD, you'll regret it if you don't!