Is this fantasy baseball trade fair?

[joer]

max scherzer, cole hamels, bj upton, ryan braun, jj hardy
for
james shields, john lackey, justin morneau, jimmy rollins, nick markakis

hitting categories are batting average, hits, on base+slugging percentage, RBIs, runs scored, total bases, stolen bases

pitching categories are innings pitched, wins, ERA, strikeouts, WHIP, shutouts, complete games


also, who do you think is better, bj upton or nick markakis?

 

[sportsmomh]

By far the top group is better. Bj is better. He does everything