I can get both phones for free, so price isn't an issue. I mainly use my phone for texting only, call's maybe 2 or 3 times a day. Since I do mostly texting, my main preference is on the qwerty keyboard...i would like a better feel. and i like my phones to feel nice, and durable. i dont want a cheap plastic thats going to fall apart. I like my phones on the heavier side, for i had the samsung a737 slider, and it felt really cheap. Thanks to everyone who answers.

PS:These are the ONLY two choices, so PLEASE dont recommend other phones! Thanks to everyone.