Should I save up for a I-pod Touch, or an T-mobile G1?

[MagunBeers]

no, i DO NOT want a i phone. ( dont have att)

[EricaR]

the G1

[Andy]

G1 would be sick because you can do everything with that. A few of my friends have the Touch though, and they enjoy it.

[Julian]

t-mobile g1 dont have 1 but anything is better than an ipod

[fashionista1125]

G1 there is more in tat then an ipod

[Why32m]

Well, it really depends.
Do you want a new phone or a new mp3 player?
I have an iTouch and I love it. The only drawback is that you need wireless to do things like go on the internet. But it's still a nice thing to have if you download Applications like Tap Tap Revenge!

[MitS]

i WOULD RECOMMEND THE G1

[lavender<3]

I don't like the ipod touch it gets all smudged up and dirty with your fingers

[alvi]

ipod touch best thing in my life had it for 5 mounths still loveing it

[nataliaehay@sbcglobalenet]

i-pod touch:
free apps and purchase apps
safari (internet)
music
videos
big 3.5 inch screen
normal apps (calculator...ect)
I-POD TOUCH!
It is way more popular than the G1 right now, I just dont see many G1s floating around...