Throughout my life dated from physically average to attractive women all whom have found me physically attractive. I was told throughout my life that I'm a decent to good looking guy.

Recently I've been using this website called okcupid.com to try to meet some women and there's a rating option in which you can rate someone 1-5 stars on looks and personality.

Suprisingly I got a few 1 star on looks / personality from some women, the majority of them either very unattractive (by society standards) or very chubby/fat (still not attractive by society's standards). Even though most people wouldn't care what they thought, it still kinda bothered me. I'm sure to most men they are not attractive, what gives them this notion that they should rate ME 1 star? Am I like unattractive to fat women or something? I don't get it