best mp3 player for me ?

i need a mp3 player that i wont use often. i will use it on the bus ...ect but not every day. i dont need alot of memory i could do with 1gb , i was thinking of a new ipod shuffle or i was looking at the creative zen 2 or 4gb. i was also looking at some phillips mp3 players but they look scratchable...what are your experiences with them and which would you think is more durable ?

I have personally used the creative zen 2 GB and i would reccomend it. Pics,videos,radio,mic,lots of music space, and a flash drive is all in it. (i think thats everything) It does scratch kinda easy but you can rub them out with your shirt. When and if it freezes you can simply stick a paperclip into the restart hole. 4 and a half stars for the creative zen!