repugnance_is_virtuous

Hi, I have a 5 year old dog, and all he ever does is whine, even when we pet him! He's whined ever since I can remember, and his sister whines too, which is our neighbors dog. How do we get him to stop, we feel like we've tried everything!!
Also, he has been whining all of his life, so I don't think it's pain, and if it is, I think he would really let us know, he runs around and plays. He's not bored, he has toys and thing to chew, we play with him ouside everyday, and not fod or water, they're always full (well, water, we feed him twice a day), he doesn't need to go pee or pooh, cuz he'll come in a whine. It's not attention, we are ALWAYS petting him.. I don't even understand why he whines so much..

david r

It might just be a habbit like humans have.
Have you asked any vets or anyone like that.
They will have more info.
I hope this helps