Thanks for all of the answers and suggestions. And to those who don't read and comprehend. I never said I can't take anything from him. I am a responsible dog owner he has been to school. He is well trained. You don't pay thousands of dollars and don't take the time out to train. That would be an idiot. He allows me to take anything from him: Bad things he is not suppose to have, food dishes while he is eating because I trained him at 7 weeks not to be food aggresive. I don't have any problems I could have taken the hoove away, but I tried to kiss him while it was underneath him. But thanks to those who actually read the question. And yes what he did was wrong. But also understand that I am dealing with a 140 pound intact dominant breed. I have had dogs my entire life. He is not bad he just did something bad.