I saw it-and I have seen the video (with Angela Lansbury and George Hearn) and I have to say, it was very good. Although Bonham-Carter's performance is a bit dry and the vocals are a little too light, her acting is very good and it is a dead-pan version totally opposite from any stage version we've seen. The little boy Ed Sanders-what a beautiful voice and Anthony was very good (did anybody else really feel scared for him-I did-still pursuing Johanna after he gets his pretty-boi ass almost killed after merely "gander"ing at her-love that added line-"you gandered, you gandered"-brilliant!) as Anthony and all the rest spectacular as well.